Accuracy and Turndown Ratio: Thermal Mass Flow vs. Coriolis Flow Meters

Accuracy and Turndown Ratio: Thermal Mass Flow vs. Coriolis Flow Meters

Introduction:

Flow meters are crucial instruments used to measure the flow rate of liquids and gases in various industries, including oil and gas, chemical, pharmaceutical, and food processing. Two widely used types of flow meters are thermal mass flow meters and Coriolis flow meters. This article aims to compare these two technologies based on their accuracy and turndown ratio.

Understanding Accuracy in Flow Measurement:

Accuracy is a critical parameter when it comes to flow measurement. It refers to how closely the measured value corresponds to the true value. In the context of flow meters, accuracy is influenced by factors like calibration, repeatability, and the technology employed by the meter.

Thermal Mass Flow Meters:

1. Principle of Operation:

Thermal mass flow meters measure flow rate by utilizing the thermal properties of fluids. They work based on the principle that heat transfer is directly proportional to the mass flow rate of the fluid. These meters typically employ a heated sensor and a temperature sensor to measure the flow rate accurately.

2. Accuracy:

Thermal mass flow meters are known for their high accuracy, with most models offering accuracy within ±1% of the reading or better. The accuracy is maintained throughout a wide range of flow rates, making them suitable for a variety of applications. However, it is crucial to ensure proper calibration to achieve the highest level of accuracy.

3. Turndown Ratio:

The turndown ratio refers to the range in which a flow meter can accurately measure fluid flow. Thermal mass flow meters generally offer a high turndown ratio, often ranging from 100:1 to 1000:1. This means that these meters can measure accurately at flow rates as low as 1% or less of their maximum flow capacity.

Coriolis Flow Meters:

1. Principle of Operation:

Coriolis flow meters operate based on the Coriolis effect, which describes the deflection of a fluid mass moving through a rotating system. These meters employ a vibrating tube, and the fluid flow causes a change in the vibration, which is then correlated to the flow rate.

2. Accuracy:

Coriolis flow meters are widely regarded as the most accurate flow meters commercially available. With accuracies as high as ±0.1%, they outperform most other flow meter technologies. The accuracy is consistent across a broad range of flow rates and fluid properties, providing reliable measurement results.

3. Turndown Ratio:

Coriolis flow meters offer a commendable turndown ratio, typically ranging from 10:1 to 100:1. This allows them to measure accurately across a wide range of flow rates without compromising accuracy. However, it is essential to consider the fluid properties and application conditions for optimal performance.

Comparison between Thermal Mass Flow and Coriolis Flow Meters:

1. Accuracy Comparison:

When comparing the accuracy of thermal mass flow meters and Coriolis flow meters, Coriolis meters have a slight edge. With their superior accuracy of ±0.1% compared to ±1% for thermal mass flow meters, Coriolis meters are often the preferred choice for applications where high precision is crucial, such as custody transfer of fluids.

2. Turndown Ratio Comparison:

While both thermal mass flow meters and Coriolis flow meters offer impressive turndown ratios, thermal mass flow meters generally offer a higher turndown ratio ranging from 100:1 to 1000:1. This makes them better suited for applications with varying flow rates, where the need for accurate measurement across a broad range of flow rates is paramount.

3. Fluid Properties:

For specific fluid properties, such as high viscosity or high temperature, the choice between thermal mass flow meters and Coriolis flow meters may differ. Thermal mass flow meters may struggle to measure accurately in high-viscosity fluids due to potential coating or fouling of the sensors. Coriolis flow meters, on the other hand, are less affected by viscosity, making them suitable for a wider range of fluids.

Conclusion:

In the end, the selection between thermal mass flow meters and Coriolis flow meters depends on the specific application requirements. If high accuracy is crucial, especially for custody transfer or precise control purposes, Coriolis flow meters are an excellent choice. On the other hand, if a wide turndown ratio is needed to measure flow rates across varying conditions, thermal mass flow meters offer a higher range. Understanding the capabilities and limitations of both technologies will assist in making an informed decision based on accuracy and turndown requirements.

Beijing Sincerity Automatic Equipment Co., Ltd have now decided to extend our company in other countries.

For more information please see our site at Sincerity Mass Flow Meter Manufacturers. Don't be hesitate to contact us!

If you are looking for best product, then here are some product like mass flow meter, rosemount coriolis mass flow meter and insertion ultrasonic flow meter in various styles which will surely meet your demand. Visit Sincerity Mass Flow Meter Manufacturers to know more!

What Beijing Sincerity Automatic Equipment Co., Ltd discovered was that innovation occurs when business models match up with one or more of the mass flow meter where technological advances overlap with market needs, thus resulting in growth and transformation.

Equipping mass flow meter with innovative technology and updated processes will simplify daily compliance duties so that they can focus on attracting, retaining, and developing the most engaged workforce possible.